October 14, 2014 at 1:35 PM EDT | By Bennett Marcus and Jenna Marotta
After news broke last week that Paul Feig has officially come aboard to direct a new Ghostbusters movie with an all-female cast, fans have been fervently speculating on which actresses will suit up. Mindy Kaling fantasy-cast a female Ghostbusters team in her 2011 book Is Everyone Hanging Out Without Me? (when she suggested a squad where she’d star alongside Emily Blunt, Taraji P. Hinson, and Natalie Portman), so when Vulture ran into her at the New Yorker Festival party this past weekend, we asked whether she still had designs on a proton pack. “I love Paul, and I would never deign to take up his time by lobbying,” she demurred. “It’s such a amazing movie, that the whole area of speculating on it is … I think it’s out of my pay grade.”